There is so much messiness in me and I don’t know if what I write is legitimate, or can be legitimated. Yet that word—legitimate, illegitimate? If I bear a child, of course it is mine. Surely it’s only men who would need to ask, wonder, try to determine: is this from me, is this of me?
Everything here is generated out of me. Shapeless as it might be—
I distract myself from the mess, everything is so messy right now, in my mind and chest and crotch, the three cauldrons my Feri teacher Valerie calls them, the cauldron of pelvis, of heart, of skull. I despise myself for not being able to write a more literary blog. I should be writing essays on Melville and Brontë and Chaucer. I should write essays on important topics, like: ________________________. (I can’t even think of a topic. Hairballs? Cooking? Cats? Back pain? Lipstick? Proust’s use of the semi-colon?)
My friend M. gave me Donald Barthelme for a birthday present, the book with sixty stories in it. I thanked him and said, does it have the one about Miss Mandible? Because I loved that, when I was a little kid and didn’t know enough to find it strange. He said yes. Then he said, a better one is “The Balloon,” start with “The Balloon” and then read backward, and then forward.
I don’t know anything. I’ve been blogging for roughly ten years and still don’t know how to say anything that’s interesting. I could never write my essays in Cambridge either. Juliet, my director of studies, tried to help me by making me write with a timer. That I could sort of do. As long as I didn’t have to adhere to an outline—I could just freewrite for an hour, and then type that up and it would be more or less an essay. And then I would be soaked in relief, and go to the midnight movie showing at the Cambridge Arts Cinema, a place I miss terribly sometimes. They’ve closed it down, of course. You could go see everything there, every film you can imagine, for £3, and you could bring in your own food. I would hand in a blotchy Shakespeare essay and then go watch a John Sayles double-feature, riding my bike home at 3 a.m. in the fog.
Today I went to two thesis defenses and a poetry reading, so I have been sitting quietly in uncomfortable chairs for a great part of the day, which has a feeling, as my Barthelme-giving friend noted dryly, of being in church, because no matter how restless you are, you can’t leave. I feel despondent for no good reason. Everything is fine. It was good to be in the MFA community again. I forget how isolated I am until I am around so many normal people and then I feel so raw and awkward, I start laughing inappropriately and wondering if everything I say just sounds like the barking of a dog. Many people congratulated me kindly about Houston, even friends who probably applied and were rejected. But I’ve been rejected by Houston before—and good news, they are allowing me travel funds to visit and look for housing in June—there is so much good news, I am fortunate—
Messy. Ugly. Nonliterary. Too personal. Uninteresting. One of the thesis candidates talked about this today, prompted by a faculty member who writes public poems, occasional poems, poems for the people. So the candidate stated in response that they too felt the need to lift the poem out of its own small circumference of focus and give it more longevity by appealing to more universal or global values. But, the candidate hastily amended, there were poems that they love just because they’re great art, not because they deal with epic themes. I was sitting there dully, thinking Hopkins, Yeats, but confusedly, because they too treat of great, spiritual themes, as well as broken-heartedness.
It used to be simple: there was le matière de Rome, le matière de Bretaigne, le matière de France. Then the troubadors came along and there was suddenly this pesky matter of elevated romantic love.
Anyway I am no doubt butchering what the thesis candidate said, but it made me uncomfortable. It was like listening to the back end of a Socratic dialogue, the side of the weaving with all the knotted threads hanging out, the rough draft that Plato never got happy with and threw away without finishing. These categorizings of poetry, even into public and private, always make me vertiginous and queasy. But I can’t explain why. I’m not a literary blogger, as much as I say I want to be, and I’m PMSing and I’m on a full milligram of Klonopin tonight because I was crying, and lately I find crying to be just unbearable. It’s not so bad, I know that, it’s human to weep, I know it’s not as bad as throwing up, or having a cut that needs stitches, or having bronchitis or strep throat. But I hate it. I fight it. I pace the casita and literally wring my hands, admonishing myself, trying to laugh myself out of it. And I take Klonopin when I PMS.
leave all your love and your longing behind
you can’t carry it with you if you want to survive
If I write it, and I am female, doesn’t that make it écriture féminine? But that doesn’t necessarily make it good? Why is my writing not better? Is it that I write at midnight after having swallowed a mood stabilizer and a benzo, with a half bottle of strawberry-flavoured mineral water and several pistachio-covered dark chocolate toffees?
My internet dating stint ended horribly and abruptly last night when a bunch of totally inappropriate guys messaged me, in their midst one person who actually seemed semi-funny and personable, even though he’s also an IT/tech type guy and not what I have lately inexplicably taken to calling, in my head, an interlectual. Jewish. Forty-something. Funny. Likes 30 Rock and Douglas Adams and Dorothy Parker (as opposed to all these guys who list, like, Animal Farm and To Kill a Mockingbird as their favorite books, because they clearly haven’t read any books since middle school), and so I was in the middle of looking at his pictures and feeling that new but already familiar revulsion, and there was something welling so I let it rise up in me and I let it, I named it, I named it was very clear: He’s not my boyfriend. I have a boyfriend, and this isn’t him. Then the next thought was equally crystalline: Why am I on this site—to meet someone and fall in love? I already met someone! I’m already in love. I’m deeply in love with someone, and none of these men on this site are him.
Then I paced the house convulsively sobbing, hiccoughing, again with the hand-wringing, fighting the urge to cry out to him, to call him to me. Like if he’s in another room of the house, I would just call his name and he would come into my office or the bedroom to see me. Where is he? Where is he? It flooded me in a matter of seconds, even the marrow of my bones melting with the urgency of the longing, it was like the last nine months didn’t exist at all, everything was so simple: I wanted him, I looked for him, I was looking around the house to find him, searching, searching, why wasn’t he there—
So tonight I went back onto the Internet dating site and disabled my profile. It’s too soon. I’m not ready. The man doesn’t exist who will cradle me against his bare chest while he reads Absalom, Absalom aloud into my hair, and I don’t want anyone else.
Then I read this poem, “Heat Shield,” by my friend Jill, it’s about her wife Josie, and it undid what was left in me. You should read it. She’s a really good poet, in that deceptively simple way that takes about a zillion hours of revisions to get right. She nailed it and that nail pierced me and then—and then nothing happened, only I sobbed and I took a Klonopin for the first time in a month and I went to bed and read Chaucer’s The House of Fame and Feminaissance until I passed out.
The last time I slept with my ex was 25 May 2010. We cried and wrestled and bit and caressed and kissed and fell asleep tangled together, he said I won’t leave you, I’m not going anywhere, and I slept like I hadn’t slept in weeks.
I dreamed Maman’s Steinway grand piano was on fire. I was trying to play something in A minor when I noticed smoke seeping out from between the keys, and when I opened the coffin-lid of the harp, the box of the piano, the flames billowed out, fire licking up along each wire. My lover and his older late-stage alcoholic brother stood there looking on. Fire! I cried out, Fire! Get blankets and water, help me put out the fire! They did nothing. I looked around, frantic; found thick woolen blankets and towels, put out the fire. Then, sooty and scorched, I turned to my lover: You had the piano insured, right? Because it’s worth tens of thousands of dollars. He turned to his brother: Yes, I gave him the money for the insurance. And then I despaired, because I knew the money had been spent on alcohol, and the piano was ruined.
I woke up alone. He’d left me a handwritten note: “Thank you, I love you, thank you, I love you, thank you, thank you.” I wrote down the dream in my journal and then got up to take a bath. I was sitting the bath with my soap in my hand when I thought, I have to leave. That afternoon I left to stay at a friend’s house for a few days. When I came back home, he and all his stuff were gone. The note is in a box somewhere where I don’t have to see it, along with his other few letters to me. He has beautiful handwriting, curved and jagged and elegant without being pretentious. I loved it. I love him.
What is writing? What is the woman trying to say? When will she turn into a tree?
What is écriture féminine? What is the meaning of experimental, what is boring, I am boring, what is trying to be less boring and has something new in it, you have to be willing to do something bad to do something new.
I still don’t understand why I can’t write essays as I know and love them, and that bothers me. Why I can only write endless accounts of what it feels like to be bereft and those aren’t interesting to any of us. Why do I not read wonderful books and tell you all about them. Tomorrow I will try to write about something that is not my failure to be on Internet dating without having unexpected hysterics.
He was the first and best reader for all of my poems. I am missing an arm, limb, or branch. The sap oozes out and covers the sawn-off oval, I keep typing “swan” for sawn, I don’t understand why I am so deeply faithful to him who was unable to be faithful to me, why I am so persistently, deeply loyal to something that doesn’t even exist.
I have allergies and keep scratching the roof of my mouth with my tongue, which doesn’t help.
This makes no sense and isn’t about what I wanted it to be about.
Here is a beautiful short film by the same friend who gave me Barthelme. If nothing else I am rich in friends, though I am not sure why. I love the billowing blue dress, and the dog. And the Satie. I love my friend for making this tiny film-poem.
The girl in the blue dress is also a poet, and a friend; she boiled creosote branches in olive oil and melted in beeswax and made a green salve that smells like the desert after a rainstorm. I put it on my cuts and blemishes every night, cupping the little container in my hands and huffing the smell to get it as deeply inside me as I can. I will miss the desert, but this will remind me of it. She is a beautiful witch.
My mother was a witch, and her grandmother; but maybe these things skip a generation.
Not only am I wondering what is experimental writing, but why can’t I write it? Why can’t I write even plain old normal writing? What is missing? Why am I lacking, why so obviously inadequate, illegitimate, why can’t I read, why do I pace around the house begging and pleading, please put out the fire in the piano, please, please? sobbing in fear. It is like I am trying to do the wrong thing. It is like I am trying to do something I’m not good at, like waiting tables or making sales calls or trying out for the drill team.
I think there was a time in my early twenties when I wrote things and I didn’t know what to do with them, there wasn’t anywhere to put them, they didn’t belong anywhere, so I shoved them back down away inside. Whereas the little princess shoes were admired, so I polished them and placed them in neat rows and that became a BA thesis, or an MA thesis. The ugly children I called names, like “unfinished novel” or “failed prose poems” or “bad short stories.” And now I’m not really sure that’s what they were. And in a sense I did it again for the MFA, setting out my brightest shiny apples in rows for the teachers.
I sent out Cherry-emily to Saturnalia today, but with a profound sense of foreboding, resignation and proleptic failure. But I did it. It seems so messy.
Now I look at people’s poems and their paragraphs and it seems everybody is doing what I cannot. Literally cannot. It is like being in a roomful of eloquent bendy willowy ballet dancers and not knowing the dance. It is like an anxiety dream, only I wake up every day and I live it.
I feel stupider and less certain of myself with every word I type. This seems worse than merely the monthly dropping estrogen, it seems like an aesthetic crisis of some kind.
Something has to fucking change around here.
